• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Benji & Jakes

Benji & Jakes, located at 5 Horseshoe Lake Rd in Kauneonga Lake, NY, offers a vibrant dining experience with stunning lake views. This popular spot boasts an extensive menu featuring delicious pizza and a variety of options for vegetarians and those seeking plant-based dishes. Guests rave about the welcoming atmosphere, attentive service, and delightful outdoor seating perfect for enjoying sunny days. The combination of flavorful dishes and a friendly ambiance makes Benji & Jakes a must-visit for locals and travelers alike. Whether you're there for a casual outing or a gathering with friends, this culinary gem promises an unforgettable experience.

Benji & Jakes: Reviews & Ratings

Lendon Ebbins
Lendon Ebbins

The pizza was great and you can’t beat the views. We had some vegetarians in our group and there were plenty of options for them. Excited to go back in warmer weather to enjoy the outdoor space.

Summer Putman
Summer Putman

Scrolling through some photos and forgot to post about this gem! We stopped here with a group of friends while out on the motorcycles and it was AWESOME!!! There is plenty of indoor seating and a bar but it was a gorgeous day so we took the seating outside on the deck. We ordered a bunch of different pizzas to share and all of them were delicious!!! Service was great, atmosphere was on point and I took my very first photo of a toilet seat in a restaurant because I never saw one like it and thought it was the coolest thing! Would absolutely come back next time we are in the area!

Tiffany Denier
Tiffany Denier

Great view of the lake. Inside and outside seating. Large menu. Loved that they had fake meat options. Food was delicious, did take a very long time to get served and it wasn't busy but overall a good experience. Will definitely be back.

Amy Smith
Amy Smith

Fabulous pizza and a varied non-pizza menu. The owners and staff are welcoming and delightful!

matthew guile
matthew guile

Called up with reservation for 13. They said "sure no problem". Had us set up in the back. We ordered many appetizers and 8 different pizzas. Amazing food!

Andrew Erskine
Andrew Erskine

This was a strange experience at a beautiful location , we were warned that they were understaffed tonight and things might take a while, but despite these delays and several false alarms with the wrong meals being brought out, when we got our food it was really good. Tasty wings, mozzarella fire sticks, corn ribs pitta and Houmus all delicious . Pizza and burger excellent too. The staff were lovely if a little befuddled and very young to be running the place , perhaps the management should help them out a bit more .

Tialisa Whipple
Tialisa Whipple

Beautiful inside and out. We had the privilege of stopping on a beautiful sunny but mild day. The staff was friendly, food was quick, plentifull and delicious. The view from the upper deck was breathtaking. We would definetly go back.

Marcus Litofsky
Marcus Litofsky

This was an awesome find. Passing through on our way to Cooperstown we stopped to check out the Woodstock concert site. We were looking for something close to the site that wasn’t a chain fast food place. The atmosphere, location, staff, and food was amazing. The T-Rex pizza was awesome! The entire staff was friendly and nice. Lucky there wasn’t a concert or festival taking place when we were there otherwise I can see how it can get busy, as there aren’t a lot of dining choices in this small town. The night we were there it seemed like it was mostly locals and everyone was friendly and welcoming.

Location

  • Benji & Jakes
    5 Horseshoe Lake Rd, Kauneonga Lake, NY 12749, United States Hotline: +1 845-583-4031

Welcome to Benji & Jakes, a hidden gem nestled in the picturesque Kauneonga Lake, NY. This vibrant eatery, located at 5 Horseshoe Lake Rd, promises a delightful culinary experience nestled against breathtaking lake views. With its diverse menu and warm atmosphere, it's a destination for both locals and visitors alike.

Benji & Jakes stands out for its fantastic pizza, which has garnered rave reviews from visitors like Lendon Ebbins, who praised the combination of delectable flavors and stunning scenery. It's not just about the pizza here; the restaurant boasts a commendable selection of vegetarian options, ensuring that everyone in your group finds something to enjoy.

Customers like Summer Putman highlight the restaurant's wonderful ambiance, particularly the outdoor seating area—perfect for enjoying meals under the sun. Whether you're riding through on motorcycles or simply enjoying a day out with friends, the lively atmosphere sets the stage for a memorable experience. The shared pizzas, praised for their excellence, create a perfect opportunity for camaraderie and culinary exploration.

The menu at Benji & Jakes extends beyond pizza, offering a variety of dishes to tantalize your taste buds. Diners have noted their positive experiences with the delicious food, though some mention that service may take a bit longer during busy times. Nonetheless, the welcoming staff and delightful offerings make the wait worth it. Tiffany Denier's review encapsulates the essence of this eatery—great food, scenic views, and options for everyone, including those seeking plant-based alternatives.

As you settle in for a meal, take a moment to appreciate the details—like the unique decor that even includes an interesting toilet seat, as noted by Summer Putman! It's these quirky touches that enhance the dining experience, making it clear that Benji & Jakes is not just another restaurant. It’s a place to gather, share, and enjoy life’s simple pleasures amidst a beautiful setting.

In summary, Benji & Jakes is more than just a dining option; it's a welcoming community spot where delicious food meets breathtaking views. Don't miss out on this perfect culinary escape the next time you find yourself near Kauneonga Lake!